Specialty Items

Our Famous Brownies

Bakery Fresh Brownies

Everyone loves a Betty Kaye Brownie. We make over 20 different seasonal flavors so its nearly impossible to pick a favorite! They make great gifts to ship to friends or family members that live in other states. We also do brownie trays and cakes for special events! They're truly perfect for any occasion!

Decorated Cookies

Bakery Fresh Decorated Sugar Cookies

Our Cutout Cookies are a very popular item these days! If you have a particular color, shape or animal in mind we'd be happy to decorate by your design!  

Decorated Cakes

Bakery Fresh Decorated Buttercream Cakes

From your child's first smash cake all the way to their wedding cake. Let us help mark the occasion with a cake from Betty Kaye.  

Daily Fresh Bread

Bakery Fresh Baked Bread

Wheat, White, Rye, Italian, Sourdough, English Muffin Bread and Various sizes of Buns for your everyday needs. 

Betty Kaye Flipovers

Bakery Fresh Dessert Cakes

Filled with our homemade mock cream and topped with powdered sugar

Daily Fresh Sweet Rolls

Bakery Fresh Sweet Rolls Breakfast Doughnuts

Every morning we fill our store with a fresh batch of Coconut or Cinnamon Rolls, Fruit filled Danish, as well as other various shapes and sizes of Sweet Rolls.